Posts
Can Europe get out of its sovereign debt crisis by adding more debt? No. Can Europe grow its way out of its current debt problem? No. It will have a difficult time growing its economy at all next year.
To make matters worse, they have a banking system that is leveraged three times higher than the U. S. banking system. But, we’re not sure because of the lack of transparency in the banking system. For example, they do not have to mark their “toxic” bonds to actual, current market prices. They can price them just about where they want. The rules were changed to keep the banks from becoming insolvent. Just like the U.S.
But unlike the U.S., they cannot do what we did to keep the banks solvent. Their government structure and the limited power of their central banking system prohibit it. This could change with new legislation but it would take time and they would have to overcome the opposition from Germany. Germany has already experienced hyperinflation caused by runaway money printing (i.e., in 1923, Germany’s inflation rate was running at 10,000% per year.)
We all know what happened to Greece recently and the moral hazard of that “agreement.” If Greece could get a 50% reduction on $200 billion of debt and additional money to spend, why wouldn’t every other country be entitled to the same?
The result of that agreement has institutional investors selling European debt as fast as they can and are now coming after Italy; next will be Spain, then France.
Italy has $2.7 trillion dollars of debt and they and must rollover $300 billion of it within the next year. They do not have the money to finance this, if they could find buyers, at an interest rate over 5.5%. Last week they sold $3 billion with an interest rate of 6.1%.
As this unfolds, major banks will have to take enormous losses. Estimates are that U.S. banks have a $600 to $750 billion dollar exposure to European banks. This could cause serious problems for American banks.
I do not know exactly how this “debt crisis scenario” will unfold over the next two weeks, two months or two years. Will the ECB get the authority to print money so they can kick the can down the road a bit longer? There is, also, severe pressure on Germany to go along and let the ECB print. Germany will have to foot much of the bill.
Therefore, the end game it seems is either default or inflate their way out of this debt crisis.
Regardless of exactly how it unfolds, I think the banks are due for a serious correction. What is in question is the timing. We may be unable to prevent this European debt crisis from happening, but there are ways to preserve your capital or profit if you know what’s likely to happen ahead of time and can position investments appropriately.
Monday, November 21, 2011
Thursday, November 3, 2011
The Zero Interest Program Is Doing Great Damage To Our Economy
Today, The Federal Reserve Indicated they would extend Zero Interest Rates beyond Mid-2013. This Zero Interest Rate Policy (ZIRP) is doing great damage to our economy. Here are a few reasons why:
1. ZIRP punishes savers and forces people to take on additional risk in order to earn needed income. Also, we need savings in order to get investment capital
2. ZRP hurts pension funds and insurance companies who depend on interest income to pay pensioners and cover insurance losses
3. ZIRP distorts prices and encourages malinvestments and new bubbles
4. ZIRP allows banks to make money from the carry-trade (by borrowing from the Federal Reserve at zero and then buying long-term Treasury bonds and capturing the difference in interest) basically risk free. We know the banks need the money.
5. ZIRP is not the way to get consumer spending back to bubble levels because the consumer credit cards are maxed out.
Also, the Federal Reserve is making things even worse with their latest “Twist” program.
This program has the Fed selling its short-term bonds (because demand is high due to world turmoil) and buying long-term bonds (10-30 years in maturity.) This is their attempt to drive down long-term interest rates to “help” the housing industry through lower mortgage rates. Someone should tell them that mortgage rates have been low for several years.
An even bigger problem is inflation. America’s $15 trillion in debt is currently financed at very low rates with an average maturity of less than five years. What happens when inflation hits and drives interest rates to the point where we cannot afford to refinance the debt we currently have? Look at the interest rates Europe is paying to get an idea (Greece two year bonds at 200% and Italy’s 10 year bonds at 8%.) Multiply that by $15 on our way to $20 trillion dollars.
What do you think is going to happen when the Federal Reserve stops buying Treasuries (the way they keep the rates down) and lets the market set interest rates based on time preference (how much interest one is willing to pay to buy the product now versus sometime in the future) and risk.
Be aware of what you can do in the current environment and prepare for higher interest rates in the future.
1. ZIRP punishes savers and forces people to take on additional risk in order to earn needed income. Also, we need savings in order to get investment capital
2. ZRP hurts pension funds and insurance companies who depend on interest income to pay pensioners and cover insurance losses
3. ZIRP distorts prices and encourages malinvestments and new bubbles
4. ZIRP allows banks to make money from the carry-trade (by borrowing from the Federal Reserve at zero and then buying long-term Treasury bonds and capturing the difference in interest) basically risk free. We know the banks need the money.
5. ZIRP is not the way to get consumer spending back to bubble levels because the consumer credit cards are maxed out.
Also, the Federal Reserve is making things even worse with their latest “Twist” program.
This program has the Fed selling its short-term bonds (because demand is high due to world turmoil) and buying long-term bonds (10-30 years in maturity.) This is their attempt to drive down long-term interest rates to “help” the housing industry through lower mortgage rates. Someone should tell them that mortgage rates have been low for several years.
An even bigger problem is inflation. America’s $15 trillion in debt is currently financed at very low rates with an average maturity of less than five years. What happens when inflation hits and drives interest rates to the point where we cannot afford to refinance the debt we currently have? Look at the interest rates Europe is paying to get an idea (Greece two year bonds at 200% and Italy’s 10 year bonds at 8%.) Multiply that by $15 on our way to $20 trillion dollars.
What do you think is going to happen when the Federal Reserve stops buying Treasuries (the way they keep the rates down) and lets the market set interest rates based on time preference (how much interest one is willing to pay to buy the product now versus sometime in the future) and risk.
Be aware of what you can do in the current environment and prepare for higher interest rates in the future.
Friday, September 23, 2011
“Print ‘Till You Drop” Update
In Scenario One: “Print ‘Till You Drop” I estimated the market would continue to drop until monetary policy (the Federal Reserve printing money) or fiscal policy (Government spending and borrowing money) began to re-inflate the economy and consequently the markets. The timing of the turnaround would be dependent on the “pain” felt by investors and politicians. My estimate was +/- Labor Day because it takes time to implement these programs and the election cycle begins to heat up.
Also, my assumption was a new stimulus program would be initiated (and one was introduced by President Obama as a “Jobs Program” for $445 billion) and a new Quantitative Easing (QE3) program from the Federal Reserve. The political mood is against more stimuli at the moment, but the Republicans can’t resist tax cuts so I assumed about $300 or $350 billion would get through the Congress. Net/Net: we basically have two options: Re-inflate the economy and markets (print ‘till you drop) or revert to a capitalist system (small government and a privately run economy.)
Since there is little chance we will go back to a capitalist system, my assumption was that the government would be “accommodative.” This assumption appeared to be correct when the debt ceiling was raised with almost no cut in spending until 2013. Then, a month ago, Fed Chairman Bernanke extended the zero interest rate policy (ZIRP) through at least mid-2013 and a statement that the Fed would remain “accommodative.” He re-iterated that statement when he was in Minneapolis a few weeks ago.
In the meantime, it was leaked that the Fed would, at minimum, initiate a “Twist” program. This program would sell about $400 billion of short-term treasuries and buy $400 billion of long-term treasuries in order to drive down long-term interest rates and help the housing industry refinance. This program would not increase the money supply (sell 400, buy 400) so it would not help re-inflate GDP or the markets. In fact, Since QE2 ended, money supply would actually contract because he did not replace the $600 billion in new money he printed for QE2. As you know, contraction takes away from GDP and thus the markets.
By the way, by itself, “Twist” will not help the housing situation either. It will also cause the yield curve to flatten (not much difference in interest rates between two year bonds and 30 year bonds) which takes the profits out of lending.
Many thought, me included, that the Fed would “surprise” the markets with additional easing or money printing. For example, stop paying banks interest for excess reserves held at the Fed which would force the banks back into the lending business. Also, to push additional money into the financial system to cause inflation (help GDP, help the markets, reduce value of the dollar to help with exports.)
On Wednesday, the surprise was that the Fed did not agree to create more money. Evidently, we have not reached their pain threshold yet. However, within hours of the Fed announcement, European markets began to fall apart again. World GDP growth rates were reduced, including the U.S. So, the question becomes: is this enough pain or do we have to wait until the next Fed meeting in November? Or is the political will to spend more money just not there?
Also, my assumption was a new stimulus program would be initiated (and one was introduced by President Obama as a “Jobs Program” for $445 billion) and a new Quantitative Easing (QE3) program from the Federal Reserve. The political mood is against more stimuli at the moment, but the Republicans can’t resist tax cuts so I assumed about $300 or $350 billion would get through the Congress. Net/Net: we basically have two options: Re-inflate the economy and markets (print ‘till you drop) or revert to a capitalist system (small government and a privately run economy.)
Since there is little chance we will go back to a capitalist system, my assumption was that the government would be “accommodative.” This assumption appeared to be correct when the debt ceiling was raised with almost no cut in spending until 2013. Then, a month ago, Fed Chairman Bernanke extended the zero interest rate policy (ZIRP) through at least mid-2013 and a statement that the Fed would remain “accommodative.” He re-iterated that statement when he was in Minneapolis a few weeks ago.
In the meantime, it was leaked that the Fed would, at minimum, initiate a “Twist” program. This program would sell about $400 billion of short-term treasuries and buy $400 billion of long-term treasuries in order to drive down long-term interest rates and help the housing industry refinance. This program would not increase the money supply (sell 400, buy 400) so it would not help re-inflate GDP or the markets. In fact, Since QE2 ended, money supply would actually contract because he did not replace the $600 billion in new money he printed for QE2. As you know, contraction takes away from GDP and thus the markets.
By the way, by itself, “Twist” will not help the housing situation either. It will also cause the yield curve to flatten (not much difference in interest rates between two year bonds and 30 year bonds) which takes the profits out of lending.
Many thought, me included, that the Fed would “surprise” the markets with additional easing or money printing. For example, stop paying banks interest for excess reserves held at the Fed which would force the banks back into the lending business. Also, to push additional money into the financial system to cause inflation (help GDP, help the markets, reduce value of the dollar to help with exports.)
On Wednesday, the surprise was that the Fed did not agree to create more money. Evidently, we have not reached their pain threshold yet. However, within hours of the Fed announcement, European markets began to fall apart again. World GDP growth rates were reduced, including the U.S. So, the question becomes: is this enough pain or do we have to wait until the next Fed meeting in November? Or is the political will to spend more money just not there?
Tuesday, September 20, 2011
The Lack Of Consumer Spending Is The Problem, Right?
Everyone knows that what is causing the recession is the “gap” in consumer spending, Right? That is the explanation according to Keynesian economics and that’s what we have been told. So after spending trillions of dollars trying to fill the consumer spending “gap” and creating $15 trillion in debt; we have been told (Paul Krugman, et.al.) that we just didn’t spend enough.
Great, so we are now about to spend some more on: 1, a new “jobs” bill that will do nothing but add to the debt and accomplish nothing long-term and 2, a new Quantitative Easing Program ( QE3 or money printing) to help the banks and hurt savers.
Printing money does levitate the market, especially when the new printed money goes to banks who can then invest it in the capital markets and in higher paying foreign investments. BUT, consumer spending is not our problem. Here are some numbers from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (dollars in trillions) that prove the point.
Year....................2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Government
Expenditures...........$4.14 $4.43 $4.73 $4.99 $5.26
Personal
Consumption............$9.52 $10.00 $9.74 $10.34 $10.45
Private Fixed
Investment
(Business
Spending)..............$2.26 $2.26 $2.12 $1.70 $1.72
This is telling us that the real problem is Business Investment. It is down by $539 billion or 23% from the peak in 2007; and running at about 76% of the 2006 level.
Isn’t this the real question: Why are businesses unwilling to invest and grow? Or is all the investment overseas where the business climate is more favorable?
Great, so we are now about to spend some more on: 1, a new “jobs” bill that will do nothing but add to the debt and accomplish nothing long-term and 2, a new Quantitative Easing Program ( QE3 or money printing) to help the banks and hurt savers.
Printing money does levitate the market, especially when the new printed money goes to banks who can then invest it in the capital markets and in higher paying foreign investments. BUT, consumer spending is not our problem. Here are some numbers from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (dollars in trillions) that prove the point.
Year....................2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Government
Expenditures...........$4.14 $4.43 $4.73 $4.99 $5.26
Personal
Consumption............$9.52 $10.00 $9.74 $10.34 $10.45
Private Fixed
Investment
(Business
Spending)..............$2.26 $2.26 $2.12 $1.70 $1.72
This is telling us that the real problem is Business Investment. It is down by $539 billion or 23% from the peak in 2007; and running at about 76% of the 2006 level.
Isn’t this the real question: Why are businesses unwilling to invest and grow? Or is all the investment overseas where the business climate is more favorable?
Tuesday, August 30, 2011
More Hopium On The Way
Our down trending economy and markets may have begun to levitate again with Chairman Bernanke’s Jackson Hole speech last week when he announced the Fed would keep interest rates at zero for two more years (that would be 4.5 years total.) I believe this is just the beginning of “QE3” (generally defined as more money printing.)
Because there is some opposition to more stimulus and money printing (including three of the Federal Reserve’s Presidents and members of Congress,) the Government and the Federal Reserve have to “justify” more spending. In other words, there has to be enough “pain” to justify more spending and interfering with the economy. I believe we will get more fiscal stimulus and more money printing because we have, over the years, turned our economy (and education, health insurance, parenting, retirement, etc. etc. over to the government) and stimulus and money printing are the only way they know how to fix things. Besides, there is an election coming soon and fixing will take time.
There are two data points coming this week that may give the government the “justification” they need. One is the ISM-Manufacturing Report on Thursday. I suspect it will be more negative than expected. The second is the jobs report on Friday. I think the consensus is for about 75,000 to 100,000 jobs. However, the data over the past month is so negative that we may see a much smaller number and even a negative number for August or September. A negative number will defiantly get attention.
These events will be followed up by President Obama’s speech on September 5th when he will tell us what his “plan” is for restoring the economy and creating jobs. I believe it will be a bigger, more expensive program than we have had to date. It will have to get through Congress, but did I mention an election is coming soon.
Also, on September 21st Chairman Bernanke will announce the decisions made by the Federal Reserve Board. If the data is bad enough, we should get QE3 almost immediately. If the data is not bad enough, we may have to wait. But we should not have to wait very long as the economy is sliding further into recession.
In summary, we may get some bad news with the ISM-Manufacturing Report and the August Jobs Report which would negatively impact the market. But, that would be immediately followed up by the President’s new stimulus plan and the Federal Reserves’ money printing plan. This hopium will levitate the market, if big enough, until +/- next Labor Day. Another short-term “fix” and a worsening long-term problem.
Because there is some opposition to more stimulus and money printing (including three of the Federal Reserve’s Presidents and members of Congress,) the Government and the Federal Reserve have to “justify” more spending. In other words, there has to be enough “pain” to justify more spending and interfering with the economy. I believe we will get more fiscal stimulus and more money printing because we have, over the years, turned our economy (and education, health insurance, parenting, retirement, etc. etc. over to the government) and stimulus and money printing are the only way they know how to fix things. Besides, there is an election coming soon and fixing will take time.
There are two data points coming this week that may give the government the “justification” they need. One is the ISM-Manufacturing Report on Thursday. I suspect it will be more negative than expected. The second is the jobs report on Friday. I think the consensus is for about 75,000 to 100,000 jobs. However, the data over the past month is so negative that we may see a much smaller number and even a negative number for August or September. A negative number will defiantly get attention.
These events will be followed up by President Obama’s speech on September 5th when he will tell us what his “plan” is for restoring the economy and creating jobs. I believe it will be a bigger, more expensive program than we have had to date. It will have to get through Congress, but did I mention an election is coming soon.
Also, on September 21st Chairman Bernanke will announce the decisions made by the Federal Reserve Board. If the data is bad enough, we should get QE3 almost immediately. If the data is not bad enough, we may have to wait. But we should not have to wait very long as the economy is sliding further into recession.
In summary, we may get some bad news with the ISM-Manufacturing Report and the August Jobs Report which would negatively impact the market. But, that would be immediately followed up by the President’s new stimulus plan and the Federal Reserves’ money printing plan. This hopium will levitate the market, if big enough, until +/- next Labor Day. Another short-term “fix” and a worsening long-term problem.
Friday, August 12, 2011
Are You Ready For Labor Day?
A lot has happened over the past week or so. I just want to cover the Federal Reserve meeting today. Fed Chairman Bernanke stated after the meeting that we are basically in a recession (my interpretation) that will last for some time; and that he will hold interest rates down until at least mid-2013. This is the normal Keynesian and Keynesian-Lite reaction to a “consumer spending gap” (a reduction in consumer spending.). Fiscal and monetary policy has been doing this (low rates and printing money) for several years now and it is not working very well.
We know that increasing the money supply increases the GDP, but maybe low interest rates and printing money are not our problem and in fact, may be prolonging our problem. However, I think the Fed believes we are still stuck in a “liquidity trap” (over simplified: I (individual, bank, company) have some money and I could borrow more, but I don’t want to spend it or buy on time or invest it because I don’t know what the future holds and if I will be able to pay it back in this uncertain economy.)
The Fed believes, to get out of this liquidity trap, they need to continue to keep rates low and flood the economy with new money which will encourage people to spend and invest. Many think this might be difficult to do now considering the recent debt debate. But this is all the Fed and the government know how to do. They can’t create jobs or fix the housing foreclosure problem or expand free trade agreements, etc. Besides, that’s what a lot of people (like Paul Krugman, et. al.) are demanding. They want the government to do something”.
Now we have a second quarter revision to GDP on August 26th. I think GDP will be revised down from 1.3% to under 1% and maybe down to as little as 0.5%. Since we are obsessed with GDP that is a problem. Two quarters under 1% growth when we need 3% growth to effect jobs growth and unemployment.
Then we have another Fed meeting on August 29th. I expect Chairman Bernanke to announce that additional help (accommodation) will be coming soon. Then throw in the fact t that Congress gets back to “work” after Labor Day and the Presidential Election season is underway.
Therefore, my assumption of Scenario One (Print Until You Drop) is that the economy may not turn up but GDP (the arithmetic model we call the economy) will turn up on new fiscal and monetary initiatives. This will then “lead” the market higher.
There are a lot of implications to this scenario on the upside and the downside for both equities and income securities. Start now to position yourself for what is coming.
We know that increasing the money supply increases the GDP, but maybe low interest rates and printing money are not our problem and in fact, may be prolonging our problem. However, I think the Fed believes we are still stuck in a “liquidity trap” (over simplified: I (individual, bank, company) have some money and I could borrow more, but I don’t want to spend it or buy on time or invest it because I don’t know what the future holds and if I will be able to pay it back in this uncertain economy.)
The Fed believes, to get out of this liquidity trap, they need to continue to keep rates low and flood the economy with new money which will encourage people to spend and invest. Many think this might be difficult to do now considering the recent debt debate. But this is all the Fed and the government know how to do. They can’t create jobs or fix the housing foreclosure problem or expand free trade agreements, etc. Besides, that’s what a lot of people (like Paul Krugman, et. al.) are demanding. They want the government to do something”.
Now we have a second quarter revision to GDP on August 26th. I think GDP will be revised down from 1.3% to under 1% and maybe down to as little as 0.5%. Since we are obsessed with GDP that is a problem. Two quarters under 1% growth when we need 3% growth to effect jobs growth and unemployment.
Then we have another Fed meeting on August 29th. I expect Chairman Bernanke to announce that additional help (accommodation) will be coming soon. Then throw in the fact t that Congress gets back to “work” after Labor Day and the Presidential Election season is underway.
Therefore, my assumption of Scenario One (Print Until You Drop) is that the economy may not turn up but GDP (the arithmetic model we call the economy) will turn up on new fiscal and monetary initiatives. This will then “lead” the market higher.
There are a lot of implications to this scenario on the upside and the downside for both equities and income securities. Start now to position yourself for what is coming.
Monday, August 1, 2011
We Again Kicked the Can, But the Road is Now Going Down Hill
The “Debt Deal” will likely pass the House and Senate today. It does not reduce the budget or spending very much. Here’s why. The base line or assumption is that the budget will grow about 7% every year (that means a 7% increase is priced in.) So, if the 2011 budget is 3.6 trillion, next year the budget will start out at $3.6 plus $250 billion or $3.85 trillion (assuming no more wars, etc.)
Therefore, in 2013 when the debt ceiling is reached again, the deficit will be $16.6 trillion rather than the $14.2 we have today; and the budget for 2014 will start at $4.1 trillion. Unless we have a national discussion about why we are spending this much money and reach a national consensus, we will continue to let politicians keep spending and monetizing our debt. If you create enough inflation to make previous debts meaningless, is that a default?
At the same time, the global economy, at a minimum, is contracting or slowing down. Therefore, the euphoria that passing the debt ceiling brings will be very short lived. We will have to immediately focus on the economy again and jobs. And there seems to be only one thing the government knows how to do, spend money and pass regulations. Also, it is only 15 months until election so stimulus and QE3 will have to be set up and implemented quickly.
Unfortunately, what we really need is for the government to get out of the way.
Therefore, in 2013 when the debt ceiling is reached again, the deficit will be $16.6 trillion rather than the $14.2 we have today; and the budget for 2014 will start at $4.1 trillion. Unless we have a national discussion about why we are spending this much money and reach a national consensus, we will continue to let politicians keep spending and monetizing our debt. If you create enough inflation to make previous debts meaningless, is that a default?
At the same time, the global economy, at a minimum, is contracting or slowing down. Therefore, the euphoria that passing the debt ceiling brings will be very short lived. We will have to immediately focus on the economy again and jobs. And there seems to be only one thing the government knows how to do, spend money and pass regulations. Also, it is only 15 months until election so stimulus and QE3 will have to be set up and implemented quickly.
Unfortunately, what we really need is for the government to get out of the way.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)